Despite the overall strength of the job market, workers’ confidence in their employers’ business outlook has reached its lowest level since 2016, according to the Glassdoor Employee Confidence Index. The decline in the index suggests that job security is a major worry for employees heading into 2024. Layoff announcements by big technology firms like Amazon, eBay, Google, and Microsoft, as well as other companies such as BlackRock, Citigroup, and Universal Music Group, have likely contributed to this pessimistic sentiment. In 2023, U.S.-based companies planned around 722,000 job cuts, almost double the number announced in the previous year. This wave of layoff announcements has certainly impacted workers’ confidence in the job market for the upcoming year.
Contradicting Perspectives on Job Market Strength
However, economists argue that these recent headlines of layoffs do not accurately reflect the overall strength of the job market. Mark Zandi, the chief economist at Moody’s Analytics, suggests that from a worker’s perspective, the job market does not seem favorable despite pockets of layoffs in specific industries. He highlights that job cuts across the broad U.S. labor market have remained near historic lows since spring 2021. Additionally, new claims for unemployment insurance are in line with pre-pandemic trends in 2019, a period characterized by labor market strength. The unemployment rate has also been consistently below 4% for two years. Julia Pollak, the chief economist at ZipRecruiter, adds that when considering the average annual unemployment rate, 2023 ranked as the sixth-best year on record, lagging behind only a few years in the 1950s and 1960s. Overall, despite the decline in workers’ confidence, the labor market continues to display robustness and resilience.
While the Glassdoor index reveals deteriorating confidence among workers, other measures indicate a more positive view of the job market and the U.S. economy. Consumer sentiment, for example, surged by 13% in January 2024, reaching its highest level since July 2021, according to the University of Michigan. Similarly, a Conference Board poll found that consumer optimism strengthened in December across all age groups and income levels. Housing values and stock prices are at record highs, and in relative terms, it seems that “everyone’s got a job,” according to Zandi.
The disparity in perspectives on the job market can be attributed to workers’ reference point. If workers compare their current outlook to what was projected for 2023 – a year during which many economists anticipated a recession – the current job market appears miraculous. However, workers are more likely to compare their current situation to a year or two ago when the job market was exceptionally strong, and they had leverage to secure better jobs and higher pay. Since then, the job market has cooled and slowed down. The Federal Reserve implemented aggressive measures to cool the economy and labor market, aiming to curb high inflation. Although the inflation rate has decreased significantly from its peak during the pandemic, the cost of consumer goods, especially essentials like food and rent, has risen noticeably. Prices are much higher now than they were two to three years ago, which has negatively impacted the average person’s buying power.
Despite the challenges caused by high inflation, there is a silver lining. Wage growth now surpasses the rate of inflation for the average person, meaning that workers’ paychecks are once again growing relative to the cost of goods. If this trend continues, consumer confidence should gradually rebound, according to Zandi. Nevertheless, workers’ concerns about job security persist, and it is crucial for employers to address these worries and foster a sense of stability and confidence among their workforce.
While workers’ pessimism about the job market may not entirely align with the overall strength of the labor market, it is essential to acknowledge their concerns. The recent wave of layoff announcements and the rising cost of living have undoubtedly impacted workers’ confidence. Understanding the different reference points from which workers perceive the job market can provide valuable insights into their mindset. Employers and policymakers must consider these perspectives and take steps to address job security concerns and foster a more positive outlook among workers.
Leave a Reply